Hello dear
Welcome To Sutter's Mill
Sutter's Mill, located in Suffern, NY, is a charming eatery that marries casual atmosphere with exceptional culinary offerings. Known for its friendly service and a nostalgic vibe, the restaurant invites diners to enjoy a menu filled with hearty favorites like French onion soup, succulent salmon, and crispy wings. Patrons rave about the frosty cold beer and the satisfying meals at old-fashioned prices. With its welcoming staff, including owner Samara, Sutter's Mill creates a community feel that's celebrated by local families. The inviting decor and attentive service make it a must-visit culinary oasis tucked away in a bustling strip mall.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Sutter's Mill
Welcome to Sutter's Mill, a charming eatery nestled in Suffern, NY, where culinary nostalgia meets modern comfort. Located at 214 NY-59, Sutter's Mill embraces an inviting atmosphere, perfect for family dinners or casual hangouts with friends. The moment you step inside, you're greeted by a warm ambiance, complete with festive decorations that enhance its friendly vibe, making it a hidden gem worth exploring.
At Sutter’s Mill, the food is undoubtedly the star of the show. Customers rave about their delectable offerings, highlighting favorites like the French Onion Soup and the crispy onion rings. With notes of savory broth and gooey cheese, the French Onion Soup has gained a loyal following. It’s comfort food at its best. Meanwhile, the onion rings and popping jalapeno peppers provide the perfect crunch for those who appreciate classic appetizers with a twist.
The reviews reflect a consistent theme: outstanding service and quality. Staff members like Dakota and owner Samara are frequently praised for their friendly demeanor, ensuring that every guest feels like family. This dedication to hospitality shines through in every interaction, contributing to the relaxed and welcoming environment. As one patron noted, "it’s an oasis of culinary magic," making it a place where you can unwind after a long day.
Food enthusiasts will also appreciate the frosty cold beer options available to complement your meal. Cold drinks perfectly pair with dishes like the wings and the remarkable NY fish sandwich. It's a match made in heaven—flavorful, satisfying, and a testament to the quality that Sutter's Mill aims to provide. It's no wonder diners find themselves returning for more, with each visit promising new discoveries from their thoroughly curated menu.
Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Sutter's Mill invites you to relish in “Great Food at Old Fashioned Prices.” The spirit of this place is not just about enjoying a meal; it’s about creating memories in a community setting. If you find yourself in Suffern, make sure to visit Sutter's Mill—for delicious food, excellent service, and an atmosphere that will leave you wanting more!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Had an awesome dinner with my family @ an old-time favorite place for Suffern. Shout out to Samara and the rest of the staff. Happy to see that Sutter's Mill is back and better than ever! ”
“ 'First time visiting Sutter's Mill, it's a great little find! The atmosphere is casual and fun, decorated for Halloween. The food was pretty good and the beer was frosty cold! The only thing missing is live music, that would be a nice touch! Dakota took our order, she was sweet and friendly, excellent service! Check it out, the onion rings and popping jalapeno peppers are great! The french onion soup amazing!! Definitely highly recommend! ”
“ Relaxing not crowded great atmosphere Their salmon is delicious as are those sweet potato fries! ”
“ Never noticed this place before, probably because it's on the end of a little strip mall at a busy intersection. It came up on my GPS so I tried it. Service was friendly and food was delicious. I had the French Onion Soup and a cheeseburger with cheese fries. I was completely stuffed but it was all soooo good. I had to laugh because the tagline on the menu says, "Great Food at Old Fashioned Prices" and my lunch with tip was 35! Oh well, it was delicious .... I'll share some pictures. The place was empty when I got there but then filled up before I left. ”
“ This is an surreal oasis of culinary magic! I walked in exhausted after a long day of work as a hospital nurse. I ordered a draft beer and wow the glass was ice cold, the beer was ice cold with perfect carbonation(very rare to find). I ordered wings next and they came out fast, big, hot and crisp, just perfect. Next I ordered the NY fish sandwich and holy s*** it was hands down amazing. It was like I was in heaven and ordered the best fish sandwich in all the clouds. The staff were uplifting and down to earth amazing and the customers were so nice too. I can't wait to go back, the menu looks so good! And the value for your money is beyond good. The owner Samara was so nice and she over sees everything to make sure everything is perfect, I will be back! ”
“ Had a great dining experience at Sutters Mill in Suffern last night. The new menu had a great variety of new choices . The Buffalo wings were just like I remembered them from years back. Our entrees were fish tacos, which were delicious.One w cod, other shrimp. Service was excellent. I highly recommend you revisit Sutters and experience the new culinary creations!! ”
“ Sutter’s Mill is back with Sam in the kitchen! Our dinner was great! Everything coming out of the kitchen looked delicious. Food is good quality and cooked the way you like it. My steak and wife’s burger were a treat to eat. We’ll be back for sure. ”
“ The chicken club was colossal!! The burger with Swiss was just delicious n juicy. The pickles r good 2. The coffee's not bad....didn't like the Buffalo wings. I asked 4 them 2 make them well done n boy did they! Lol, I did ask 4 grilled onions on my burger n I must say the onions where grilled nicely! The food was on point. Did I mention how big the chicken club is lol go enjoy! ”